Moving out of the City: Something Gained, Something Lost.

December 16, 2012

Moving out of the City: Something Gained, Something Lost.

In the Mad Men era, there was little question that dad would be commuting to work.

Maybe it’s because this is the first year where all of our kids are away at college, or maybe it’s a symptom of me always thinking about the What Else; in any case, I’ve been thinking a lot about parenting.

Recently I was mulling over the phenomenon of people who live and work in a city, but move their family to a suburb when they have kids, so that the kids can grow up in a more rural, “safer” area, with supposedly better schools.

The equation goes something like this:

Better schools + Safer, more calm environment = Better way of growing up for the kids

But I think many of the families that subscribe to this equation ignore a key factor.

Usually, when a family moves out of the city, at least one of the parents keeps working in the city (if not both). So they spend at least a couple of hours every day - and often more - traveling to and from the city for work.

This means that while the kids are attending a better school, and have a yard to play in, they’re probably spending less quality time with their parents. Because no matter what the logistics are, when you work in a different city than where you live, you’re necessarily away from home more.

And as I’ve written before, that’s time you’ll never have back.

So a more realistic equation might be:

Better schools + Safer, more calm environment – Time with parent = Better way of growing up for the kids?

I don’t know the answer to this.

Can a good school be worth a kid seeing his dad or mom less?

Any time we make a decision, there’s a value proposition and an opportunity cost in it. Which is another way of saying there’s always something gained, and something lost.

You can’t eat your cake and have it, too.

Do people weigh all the factors enough when they move their families?




Leave a comment


Also in "What Else?" Blog

Getting the Most from Life is a 3-Step Miracle
Getting the Most from Life is a 3-Step Miracle

October 20, 2017

There are three very simple steps to getting what you want out of life.

Continue Reading

Don’t Worry About the Fire, Worry About the Thing That Makes the Fire
Don’t Worry About the Fire, Worry About the Thing That Makes the Fire

October 18, 2017

Too often we take losses too hard and we jump to the conclusion that there is something wrong before considering a loss as an opportunity to learn that will make our next game, business pitch or sales call a success.

Continue Reading

You've Lost The Exact Moment You Decided To Give Up
You've Lost The Exact Moment You Decided To Give Up

October 16, 2017

On the most recent episode of my podcast, Unplugged with Brandon Steiner, I spoke with 4X World Series Champion Darryl Strawberry. 

Continue Reading